Zabul Province, Afghanistan
Our convoy pulls into Forward Operating Base Lagman at 1200 hours. After three embeds in Iraq, Im finally visiting "the forgotten war," fought in a truly exotic land rich with history. In fact, Ive just seen The Castle, an amazing fortress the locals claim Alexander the Great built. So what am I thinking? My butt hurts. Its been six straight hours in a Humvee along Highway One from Kandahar Airfield and the only exercise Ive gotten is shifting in my seat.
My escorts are from the Romanian 812th Infantry Battalion. It might have been easy to dislike them because I was exhausted from my flight the previous day and they made me get up at 0300 to grab that oh-so-uncomfortable seat. But of the 37 NATO countries providing 35,000 personnel in Afghanistan, Romania is one of only six (besides the U.S.) that actually allow their men to fight. They deserve gratitude.
Zabul Province, our destination, is north and east of Kandahar, heading towards Kabul. Its an important Taliban gateway from Pakistan, one of five southern Pashtun provinces (out of 34 provinces total), meaning the Taliban have some measure of local support since they arose within that ethno-religious group. Days before I arrived, 16 Afghan National Army (ANA) ambush casualties arrived at FOB Lagman, overwhelming the small aid station and turning infantry and engineers into medics. (All survived.) The now-cocky Taliban then tried to repeat the trick, but this time U.S. airpower hammered them, killing at least 35. ("Taliban," incidentally, is the generic term for the enemy, used now to describe not only that group but also al Qaeda and other terrorists; the military-approved jargon is Anti-Government Elements or AGE.)Lagman operates under the auspices of a Provisional Reconstruction Team (PRT) run by the U.S. Air Force. As the name indicates, the team handles civil-affairs projects in Zabul. But the Romanian Army runs the military side. Romanian M.P.s police the nearby mud hut village of Qalat, which they tell me is fairly safe although they wont let me patrol with them there. Two weeks after I arrived the Afghan National Army would have a gun battle there, seizing what proved to be the headquarters of Mullah Dadullah, a butcher frequently called "the military mastermind of the Taliban insurgency." On May 13, Afghan and U.S. forces killed Dadullah in Helmand Province.
The Romanians main job, however, is to patrol the 93-mile stretch of Highway One that runs through Zabul and to support the Afghan National Police (ANP) stations that line it so as to keep the highway as free as possible from Taliban interference. The Romanians launch about 50 missions a week down the highway and also have a quick reaction force in case the police stations request help. They have taken no casualties during this deployment, but previous Romanian units here were less lucky.
Highway One is vital; its recent repaving after decades of war-related pummeling has tremendously shortened the drive time from Kandahar to Kabul. Of all the civil-affairs projects underway in Afghanistan, probably none is more important than tying the nation together with good roads that facilitate both military and commercial transportation. The latter often goes by way of brightly colored jinga trucks that the Americans call "jingle trucks" and that do indeed often jingle from chimes attached to the back. (Afghans love color, as evidenced also by the nomads tents and the flags used to mark graves. I even saw an Afghan soldier with a brightly colored AK-47.)
Lagman has a small contingent of Americans who control the other forward operating bases in Zabul, plus a fire base that provides artillery. These are from the 1st Infantry Battalion, 4th Infantry Regiment based in Hohenfels, Germany. During the Indian wars and the War of 1812, the 1-4 Infantry was commanded by future President William Henry Harrison. Today it serves primarily as OPFOR, or Opposing Force, to other units in training. In Afghanistan its gone from playing the Taliban to fighting them.
FOB Lagman is not a fun place, although at least theres no rule requiring constant body armor, as was the case where I stayed in Ramadi, Iraq. Lagman doesnt get shelled. Im squeezed in with two AP video reporters from Spain in a room meant for one munchkin. There is a tiny PX, but it periodically closes to make supply runs to Kandahar. There are all of four male showers here, two with curtains missing. The water is hot, though. There is only one computer with an Internet connection. Parts of the camp are made of mud.
Apparently they have cobras here – by which I do not mean Marine AH-1 gunship helicopters so nicknamed, but the kind that slither, hiss, and, if youre unfortunate, bite. The doctor across the way from me, Capt. Richard Slusher, assures me we have no antivenin. On the upside, its good incentive to keep the place clean, because trash brings rodents and rodents bring snakes. They also have the ugliest, nastiest beetles Ive ever seen. The little monsters fly and bite. Im pretty sure they report directly to Osama himself.
One of the AP reporters says he believes 9/11 was a Bush administration conspiracy hung on al Qaeda. Slusher gives him hell about it – albeit in a good-natured way. I dont hear the other reporter sound out on the subject, but he never takes off his Che Guevara T-shirt. Maybe these two will provide unbiased footage and commentary notwithstanding their personal views – maybe not.
Some embeds pride themselves on getting interviews with high-level officers. But Ive found that comments from lieutenant colonels and higher start to become infused with politics. The higher you go, the greater the BS-to-truth ratio. If you want spontaneous opinions you stick with lieutenants through majors, along with non-coms. That can even be true when you want to discuss politics, as was the case when I interviewed the commander of the Transylvania-based 812th, Maj. Ovidiu Liviu Uifaleanu.
Romania has about 750 soldiers in Afghanistan, 550 men and a few women under the 812th at Lagman. Their uniform camouflage patterns resemble something like rust-colored tiger claw marks on a yellowish background. While the American combat uniforms no longer allow the sleeves to be rolled up, the official Romanian uniform includes shorts, short-sleeved shirts, and even camouflage T-shirts with epaulets indicating rank; therefore, the soldiers can be in T-shirts while also being in full uniform. These people understand comfort.
Romania, as noted, is among the handful of allied countries with troops here that actually fight. The fighting countries ranked by total troop presence are the United States, Britain, Canada, Denmark, the Netherlands, Romania, and Estonia. The other NATO participants, many of them vastly larger than Estonia (with a population of 1.3 million, about the size Phoenix), have issued "caveats" – rules that basically forbid their forces to fight or even to go outside severely limited areas. These include Germany (83 million), France (64 million), Italy (58 million), and Spain (40 million). The mere presence of Italian troops threatened to bring down that nations government, while Frances new president, Nicolas Sarkozy, hinted in late April that he would shortly bring Frances approximately 1,000 troops home.Why Romania? I ask Uifaleanu. "We are a NATO country and our mission is established by the government," he says. "We are obligated by NATO membership." Spoken like a true soldier. I ask the major (and thats what I call him, for fear of mispronouncing his name) why Romania feels this obligation when so many fellow NATO members do not. "At higher echelons they make those decisions," he says. "We are keeping our promise as a member of NATO." That does imply, of course, that perhaps the others are not.
There are also about 700 Romanian troops in Iraq, most of whom operate out of Camp Dracula in Tallil. Dracula – also called Vlad Tepes or "Vlad the Impaler" – is a hero to Romanians because, despite his rather unorthodox methods, he did keep the Turks at bay, if only temporarily. Uifaleanu does say that theres strong support back home for the Afghan contingent remaining, while not so for the one in Iraq.
Heres an alternative answer for why Romania fights. Much of what Donald Rumsfeld, prompting great anger, called "Old Europe" has grown lazy, weak, and decadent. Even though many countries are at far greater risk from Islamist terror than is the United States, because they have huge populations of disgruntled Muslims, theyre delighted to let others do the fighting and dying. Romania, like Estonia, after years of involuntary servitude in the Soviet empire, is delighted to have joined what remains the worlds leading military alliance, and it wants to do its part.
A Depressing Day at the Police Stations
Although Afghans like to call the American Humvees "tanks," there is really no U.S. armor to speak of in Zabul. The Romanians have brought their own in the form of the B33 Zimbrul, an eight-wheeled armored personnel carrier based on a Russian model. The Zimbruls main KPV machine gun fires what may be the worlds largest non-explosive rounds at 14.5 millimeters, or .57 caliber. Those bullets wouldnt just easily pass through a mud hut; they would probably enter the front wall of the first hut in a village and exit the back wall of the last hut. Thats one reason its important to carry a smaller secondary gun, in this case, a 7.62 millimeter PKT. My hosts gave me the opportunity to fire both machine guns, and I think the KPV rattled a few fillings loose. "Our preceding unit here fell into two or maybe three ambushes," Uifaleanu says. "But the Taliban have learned."
The Taliban are also learning it can hurt to fight against the 32,000-member Afghan National Army. The ANA is better equipped, better trained, and better paid than the National Police. The Afghan army platoon at FOB Lagman is equipped with new-looking American woodland camouflage uniforms, body armor for everyone, and AK-47s in top shape. Most Iraqi army units may be unwilling to take the fight to the enemy; not so the Afghans. "They are very aggressive in the field," says Uifaleanu, "very eager to kill the Taliban." Others I speak with, including non-coms, say the same.
Unfortunately, the police arent nearly as impressive. Courtesy of a small Romanian convoy, I visited four police outposts along Highway One. Each had a complement of about 15-20 men. The first thing you notice about these buildings is that while they have some blast and antipersonnel protection, the level of protection is low. Ideally they would all be surrounded on the outside by razor concertina wire to keep the Taliban at a distance. There would be an inside barrier – made of huge dirt-filled thick polypropylene material bags called Hescos – to provide blast protection against rocket-propelled grenades. Sandbags would protect the roof. In fact I saw little wire, and the Hescos and sandbags protected only part of the perimeters. Some of the buildings had sandbags on the roofs for protection against light mortars, others didnt.
In terms of weapons and ammunition, they were no better off. I wont give exact numbers for security reasons, but for their AK-47s they had just enough ammo to sustain a brief firefight (fortunately most are quite brief). At one station, they were delighted to inform us not just how many AK magazines they had per soldier but that the magazines were completely filled. Ouch! It doesnt help that like Iraqis (or untrained soldiers anywhere), they have a tendency to fire not single shots or controlled bursts but rather to hold the trigger and let fly with a good chunk of the magazine.
Every outpost was given an RPG-7 – the venerable Soviet grenade launcher – and one had a pair, but again with little ammunition. Each station had one 7.62 millimeter RPK machine gun. For these, the police seemed to have a more decent ammo supply.
Fortunately, these outposts arent overrun as often as you might think. The Taliban carry light weapons, nothing heavier than an RPK or RPG. Maybe a mortar tube, but with no base plate, so it cant be fired accurately. If the fighting does get thick, stations can call for the Romanian quick-reaction force. But the Taliban know how long it takes the Romanians to arrive and are careful to be gone by then. So the potential Romanian firepower is what really counts.
Not being overrun seemed near the limit of what these outposts could do. At one station they told us, "We ask in the villages, Why are you helping the Taliban? and then they say, They take our sons and brothers and theres nothing we can do." At another: "We see Taliban driving by on motorcycles, but we dont have good weapons to shoot them."
Lest I be accused of violating operational security by revealing this, the Taliban obviously can see the fortifications and can determine ammo supplies with probes. When they fire several RPG rounds at an outpost and receive only one in return, that tells them something. The Taliban know; its time the American public knew, too.
Bribes and Bullets
All the Romanians can tell the police is, "Well try to give you enough ammo and enough weapons." But for the time being its a pipe dream. Consider that an AK bullet costs about 17 cents. Thats a little over $5 for a full magazine. For a 15-man station, we could provide each policeman another magazine for about $80. Meanwhile, a single Hellfire air-to-surface missile costs $100,000.
The police themselves are a ragtag bunch, ranging in age from perhaps 14 to 70. A few wear raggedy blue official summer uniforms, while some of the younger guys at one outpost wear thick wool winter gray uniforms that look like they came from a stockpile of the Confederate States of America. Even the caps look Confederate. But most of the police wear civilian clothes, which isnt good. A uniform helps hold a unit together, and it gives a man pride.
The worst deficiency, though, is pay. While their salaries are merely $70 a month, none of the police had been paid in three months. (To use the Hellfire comparison again, one missile would pay more than 1,400 police salaries for a month.) Obviously this discourages recruiting, and when those police do finally get paid it may encourage them to take the money and run.
Less obvious, except to anybody who knows the history of Afghanistan, is that bribes are more important than bullets. In fact, the conquest of the country from the Taliban began when the CIA flew in $3 million in cash (they would eventually spend many times that) to win over warlords to the Northern Alliance.
So the Taliban know that far more important than any weapon in their arsenal is the wad of cash supplied by sympathetic Arab oil sheikhs, Islamic charity front groups, and Osama bin Laden himself. According to a February report from the Center for Strategic and International Studies, "In some reported cases, the Taliban are paying up to $12 a day, three times as much as the [Afghan National Army] field soldiers, and there is evidence of defection from the national security forces to the Taliban ranks."
More than that, a lack of funds encourages some police to sell what weapons they do have. I asked B Company executive officer Lt. Keith Wei if it would be possible to supply the police with DShKs (pronounced "dishka"), a Russian-made 12.7 millimeter antiaircraft weapon adapted for ground combat. It would clean the Talibans clocks. He was politely aghast at my ignorance. "Because theyre receiving no salaries, there would be tremendous temptation to sell those to the Taliban," he said. And DShK rounds can slice through Humvee armor.
Retired General Barry R. McCaffreys February 2007 Afghanistan report, based on personal observation but primarily outside data, is generally upbeat. "We are now on the right path," it concludes. Nevertheless it also states, "We have no real grasp of what actual [Afghan National Police] presence exists at the 355 District level operations. . . . We do know that 50 percent more Afghan police were KIA last year than [Afghan army] soldiers." It continues, "The task of creating 82,000 Afghan policemen (currently a notional 62,000 force) is a ten-year job that we must fully resource," and we are now beginning that. Yet "the effort to create the Afghan police is currently grossly under-resourced with 700 U.S. trainers." By contrast, he notes that in Kosovo we had 5,000 police mentors for 6,500 Kosovo police.
In the short term, though – which is to say right now – the police need weapons and ammo and proper uniforms for hot and cold weather. Most critically, we need to pay them their lousy $70 a month.
Hearts and Minds
Meanwhile the Provincial Reconstruction Teams, the U.S. Agency for International Development, the U.N., and other agencies work to win over the people with public works projects in Zabul – building bridges, roads, police stations, fire stations, and schools. The United Arab Emirates funded a state-of-the-art teaching hospital. Twenty-four PRTs are stationed across Afghanistan with six, including Zabuls, headed up by the Air Force. Each team has about 90 members, including 40 active-duty airmen.
The Zabul PRT established a trade school with courses on basic computer operations, welding, automobile mechanics, plumbing, carpentry, electrical installation, construction, emergency medical technician training, nursing, and an agricultural extension program. The Taliban will probably always be able to offer tempting payments to Afghan men to take potshots at NATO and Afghan troops, but not necessarily enough to make it worth employed ones risking their lives. The PRT in May conducted a medical outreach for the Mizan district, treating more than 200 patients. Qalats mud huts are being wired for electricity, although actually providing it will be a much more difficult task. Rebuilding long-neglected dams seems the best bet.
All of this information, incidentally, is from web searching. A PRT member at Lagman emailed that he was "very disgusted" with me "for the type of reporting you do" – indicating it was too negative. "Why dont you even mention what is being done in Zabul province by the PRT?" Alas, my repeated efforts to obtain information from the Provincial Reconstruction Team, including emailed requests for a spokesman to answer informational questions for just a few minutes, were rebuffed. I finally emailed the executive officer in disgust:
So much for military complaints that the media only focus on explosions and killings while ignoring hearts and minds projects. It appears the mainstream media arent as blameworthy in this regard as I thought. Unconventional wars are won or lost as much in the media as on the battlefield; its unfortunate that the Air Force apparently doesnt realize that.
This is a little harsh on the Air Force generally, but I promised him that "as someone who sees this war as something to be won, I will be writing about this."
So I have.
Forward Operating Base Mizan is home to the 1st Platoon of Bravo Company, 1-4 Infantry, and a platoon of Afghan National Army with three American embedded training team members. The other FOBs and firebases in Zabul are manned by other platoons of B Co. Mizan is perhaps a 25-minute helo ride from Lagman. My chariot is a CH-47 Chinook, the workhorse of Afghanistan. Relatively few UH-60 Black Hawks are used, because the Chinooks huge twin rotors provide valuable extra lifting power in the thin mountain air. The FOB is not nearly as Spartan as I was originally led to believe. I was told in Kandahar they might not have electricity and therefore to juice up everything electronic I had before coming. But there is plenty of generator power. Its true that for the previous month they had been without an Internet connection because lightning fried an antenna, but a techie came on the same bird I did and got it back up. They have showers using water pumped from a well dug two months ago, although showers may no longer be available as we head further into the dry season and the water table drops. The water is usually heated, and they have hot chow.
Amazingly, they have essentially a full gym, with free weights, barbells, an elliptical device, and a treadmill. It was here when 1st Platoon arrived. The camp is too small for the men to go on runs, and the patrols are all mounted because everything is so spread out. So a gym is the only way the men can really keep fit, and its a real morale-booster. Bathroom facilities are crude, as youd expect. Waste is burned daily by some recently hired young Afghans who live inside the wire. Media sleeping quarters are a narrow bit of hallway between the soldiers quarters and the door, shared with the techie while he awaits a helo out, and featuring constant foot traffic during the day and evening.
Whats truly impressive is how well protected this place is. Im told the camp, begun by the 173rd Airborne Brigade and later occupied by the 10th Mountain Division (Light Infantry), is far better in terms of both safety and creature comforts than just a few months ago. Hescos, sandbags, and concertina wire are everywhere. As at Lagman, the Americans have no armor but they have lots of late-model Humvees with a mix of M-2 .50 caliber and M240 7.62 millimeter machine guns and MK-19 40 millimeter automatic grenade launchers in the turrets. The camp also has several mortar tubes of various sizes. Conspicuously absent is an American flag. Its part of the effort to look like were here to help, not to occupy.
The compound is busy as a beehive, which contributes to morale by reducing boredom. In my few days there, I see soldiers make both sides of the "safe house" (their quarters) even safer by extending the roof and building two new walls of sandbags. The dining facility has been sandbagged only about halfway up because they keep running out of filled bags. (I overhear one GI on the phone say they call the FOB "the Sandbag Palace.") A TV is installed just after I arrive, though strangely enough it only seems to receive sports channels. An open phone booth is also installed inside the dining facility, which has only one or two tables when I arrive but is soon filled with enough freshly built tables to accommodate everyone.
To beat the heat, soldiers get up at 0400, and the sawing and hammering begins at 0430. Summer dress here is "military casual," with jackets rarely worn and sandals almost as common as boots.
Morale seems excellent, much better than I would have expected from a unit in the middle of nowhere that rarely gets to engage the enemy. (Its not being shot at, but rather getting a piece of the enemy that boosts spirits.)
The commander of this impressive outpost is 1st Lt. Kevin Stofan, from Miami Springs, Florida. At 28, hes a bit old for his rank. But thats because he only joined the Army in March 2005. "I got tired of sitting on the sidelines," he says. "Pretty much the reason I joined was to go to war. I was happy to deploy to Afghanistan."
FOB Mizan wasnt plopped down here to keep the Taliban out, which is simply beyond its capability. In Zabul as a whole, theres only one NATO or Afghan soldier per seven square miles, and the ratio may be worse in Mizan. Rather, the idea is to inhibit the movement of the Taliban and improve security in Mizan district. The FOBs 120 millimeter mortar, with a maximum range of four and a half miles, is an impressive weapon. Directed from any of the numerous observation posts that scan the countryside, the 45-pound shells can hit the Taliban anywhere on the inside of the mountain range that surrounds the camp. I watched a drill on an almost pitch-black night. Within about five minutes the soldiers had the big tube blasting away, one round right after another.
But patrols are the main tool for keeping the Taliban on the run. "With random patrols their movement is completely inhibited because they never know when well be there," says Stofan, "and they do not want to fight us. They dont have the numbers; they dont have the discipline and skill; and they dont have the weapons."
Unfortunately, unless you employ up-armored donkeys, about a third of the region cant be reached by patrols. Yet even patrols cant secure a village. "You have to be there on a permanent basis," says Lt. Stofan. "The villagers worry about the Taliban because they strong-arm people for shelter or food and then move on to the next town," he continues. "When they pass through in large numbers they leave behind nuisance guys to close schools and clinics by kidnapping teachers and doctors and scaring off road crews." A week before I arrived, Taliban killed five Afghan security guards protecting a road construction project in the Mizan district.
"The last school in Mizan closed two years ago," says Stofan, "yet about 50-60 percent of the population is less than 14 years old. Theres a rapidly growing younger generation not getting educated. There is some Koran teaching going on, and I asked the instructor if hed expand teachings to grammar and math if I obtained the books." The teacher agreed, and two months later he got them.
Except perhaps for additions to the base, everything moves slowly out here – sometimes imperceptibly so. Literacy rate estimates for Zabul range from 1 percent to 15 percent but in either case its the worst in the country and its even lower for women. In fact, I never saw a woman the whole time in Zabul except for nomads along the highway. The nomads are the least culturally strict people in the country. "You could take a picture of one of these villages and it would look like something out of a nativity scene," says Stofan. I did, and they do.
Numerous crops grow in Zabul, but you can guess which one is most important economically. On one Mizan patrol our Humvee became mired in mud and I was able to get out and walk around a bit until called back to the vehicle when six apparent Taliban moved into position across an easily fordable river from us. I came to a low mud wall, looked over, and – lo! – several acres of beautiful, deadly poppies. Poppy eradication is not working in Afghanistan. Opium production rose a startling 59 percent last year over the year before, notwithstanding USAIDs assertion that it would be cut by 30 percent. But we need to consider the possibility that it shouldnt work, at least for now. Raising the flowers is apparently 70 times more lucrative than raising wheat, with wheat barely allowing farmers to break even. "Opium cultivation accounts for nearly 60 percent of the countrys gross national product," according to USAID. Waging a "drug war" while at the same time waging a real war may be too much to ask of already greatly overstrained resources.
The Zabul Afghans
Iraqis are world champion complainers. Not so here. "I have never heard an Afghan complain," says Lt. Stofan. "It is always in the form of if you have this or we could really use this." It is always followed by the disclaimer "We are very thankful for what you have already given us." Even the elderly Pashtun arent nearly as reserved as youd expect. They love to chat, always accompanied by chai tea (which in Afghanistan is simply black or green tea sweetened with sugar). Thats understandable because with virtually no TVs, computers, iPods, or reading ability, chatting is about the only pastime there is. Further, observes Stofan, "one thing I appreciate about them is that although they may believe in one thing or another they are not judgmental on our values or traditions. They respect the fact that we shave or keep our shoes on indoors, for example, because it is what we do. They are not offended by it or frown upon it."
The younger Afghans are quite outgoing. I was first introduced to those who live on the base when I began talking to one whose job was burning feces – as good a way to meet someone as any. Two were "terps" (interpreters) who kept insisting I take their photos knowing I would nevertheless have to delete them immediately for their own safety. I remarked to Stofan that I thought they liked me a bit too much because our frequent chai chats were cutting into my work time. He offered that I ought to see them on Thursday nights when they dress up as women and commented on the pervasiveness of homosexuality in the Pashtun culture, a result of severe segregation of the sexes.
Later I meet the district chief, Mohammed Younis, and the young police chief commander, Mohammed Khan (nicknamed "Krazy Bone"). He has the thickest shock of hair Ive ever seen on a man, resembling a black-colored eagles nest. He continually runs one hand through it while his other seemingly seeks gold deep inside his nose. Still, I am told Krazy Bone is a top-notch police chief, despite his idiosyncrasies and his youth, and his men really do seem to have their act together. Younis, conversely, is a picture of dignity in his turban and white flowing clothes.
Guarding the gate to Youniss compound is a Hollywood image of a mujahedeen dressed in dark blue. Again demonstrating the Afghan love of color, he has a little orange ribbon attached to the wire stock of his AK-47 (see photo at right). He wears a hammer-and-sickle belt buckle presumably taken from the body of a Soviet soldier or a member of the old Communist government army. Atop his head is a brown pakol, a flat wool cap indicating he fought under Ahmed Shah Massoud. Massoud was the most effective commander against both the Soviets and as head of the Northern Alliance against the Taliban until al Qaeda assassinated him two days before 9/11.
Its fascinating to watch Stofan converse with Younis via the terp. In America, we usually exchange pleasantries and then get down to business. In Afghanistan, you exchange pleasantries intermittently throughout any conversation, such as asking a man about his recent pilgrimage. The first order of business is compensation for a man whose house was accidentally struck by an American bomb, wounding eight residents. He was to receive about $4,000 and Stofans main concern was that this was an old man who would be walking from town carrying a heck of an incentive for a mugging. (He would later make it back safely.)
The district chief agrees, but seems more interested in money to support his operations. You cant blame him. He says Krazy Bones men havent been paid in five months. "We can fight better if we are paid," he insists while fingering his prayer beads. He then quickly adds that he thinks the problem has nothing to do with Americans but rather is a bureaucratic snafu in Qalat and that the money will be arriving soon. Stofan promises he will ask "my boss," meaning Deputy Task Force Zabul Commander Maj. Christopher Clay, to intercede, and says that in the past such efforts have met with success.
The district chief also offers that the townspeople like us very much and that when American or Afghan soldiers disrupt their lives with raids, the locals "blame it on the Taliban" for prompting the raids. Is it true, I wonder, or does he say this simply to be hospitable? After hours of conversation I conclude that this is a man who speaks his mind, and if he says the townspeople are savvy enough to realize that the Taliban are the root of any problems with the military, he means it. In one conversation Stofan tells Younis that if he gets some money he will buy pomegranates from the locals, but Younis wont hear of it. "We will give them to you," he says, waving his hand, "all that you need."
A WorldPublicOpinion.org poll released last December indicates that the district chief and his people are no exception in their hatred of the Taliban; a scant 7 percent of Afghans said they have a positive view of them, fewer than in a poll 11 months earlier. They have not forgotten the horrors of the Taliban version of Sharia Islam, which stacked extremism upon extremism. Aside from that, its important to understand that Afghans see even Afghan Taliban as foreigners and intruders. Thats because unlike in Iraq, the insurgents are rarely local. If youre not from their village, youre not one of them. The Taliban themselves generally feel they dont belong to any country, and who are the Afghans to disagree? Meanwhile, only 25 percent of those surveyed said they had a somewhat or very unfavorable attitude toward the U.S. forces in Afghanistan, although that is a higher figure than 11 months previously.
Encouraging also is a mid-2006 poll from the San Francisco-based Asia Foundation that found 77 percent of respondents say they are satisfied with the way democracy works in Afghanistan. Another favorable marker is that slightly over half say theyre more prosperous than under the Taliban, while only a fourth say theyre less prosperous. In fact, USAID reports the countrys economy, not counting opium sales, is growing a robust 12 percent per year. Finally, almost 90 percent say they trust both the Afghan army and police.
They are by no means deeply content. Forty-two percent think the progress of reconstruction is excellent or good, leaving 58 percent thinking its fair or poor. And while 62 percent still think their nation is going in the right direction, thats down substantially from 83 percent in the poll 11 months before. In other words, we still have plenty of good will in Afghanistan, but were in danger of squandering it.
A Winnable War
I cant say how often I heard officers or noncoms say, "This war is winnable." Implicit is that its also losable; but what they really mean is winnable in comparison to Iraq. Its strange but true that Afghanistan – with four major ethnic groups, two official languages, and almost countless lesser languages – is far more of a proud, united nation than Iraq. They have Sunni and Shia, but their differences are just another excuse for a chat over chai. Its way too early to say if the Iraqi "surge" is working, but the much-anticipated massive Taliban spring offensive in Afghanistan has thus far proved a trickle rather than a deluge.
Still, it would be a mistake to assume time is on our side. Afghans seem to be losing patience with the war effort, and while that may not help the Taliban, it can certainly hinder President Hamid Karzai in his efforts to keep the warlords at bay. Its warlords, not sectarianism, that pose the internal threat. The most powerful of these is General Abdul Rashid Dostum, one of the Northern Alliance leaders against the Taliban. But before that, he fought on the side of the Soviets and the Communist government. Probably to undercut the government, which has essentially excluded him, he announced in May that he can raise an army and drive out the Taliban in six months.
Pakistani president General Pervez Musharraf has just called for negotiating with the Taliban, and a new survey shows almost two-thirds of Canadians think we should parley. Last October, Senate majority leader Bill Frist also called for negotiations, as did a Canadian think tank report in March. This would be like going to dinner with Hannibal Lecter, insofar as the Taliban are fairly inept militarily but once negotiated and bribed their way to control as much as 95 percent of the country. Yet now even the Afghan Senate has voted for a truce to be followed by negotiations and withdrawal of NATO forces.
Of course, if Musharraf were serious about ending the war, he would stop his double-dealing. For all his talk about negotiations, his own granted the Taliban what amounts to autonomy in the lawless border region of Waziristan ostensibly in exchange for a promise not to cross into Afghanistan to fight. The Taliban instantly broke the deal, but now Musharraf says the West needs to learn from his actions. Indeed, it should.
Moreover, at some point were going to start wondering why we fight so hard to keep al Qaeda out of Afghanistan when theyve shown theyre perfectly capable of running operations out of western Pakistan. General Dostum sweetened his offer to restive Afghans by saying his men wouldnt stop at Afghanistans borders but would sweep into Waziristan as well, the main Taliban and al Qaeda sanctuary, which Musharraf tolerates. Although Musharraf fears Pakistani Islamists as a threat to his own power, he has no problem with them if theyre isolated. He is no friend of Afghanistan. If the Taliban were uprooted from Waziristan, it would not only destroy al Qaedas new headquarters but tremendously shorten the length of the war.
Fought on a Shoestring
Ive only been in small parts of Iraq and a small part of Afghanistan, but Ive seen enough to know that while the Iraq effort is awash with money but lacking in men, the war in Afghanistan is being fought on a shoestring in terms of both. There will be about 155,000 U.S. troops in Iraq when the U.S. buildup is complete, but there are only about 27,000 U.S. troops in Afghanistan, a country larger in both geography and population. A massive concrete blast wall in Iraq is a mere mud wall in Afghanistan. "It takes four weeks here just to get cement," Lt. Wei says. "We need to help build and to provide security, but we just dont have the funds. Everybody here understands what needs to be done but their hands are tied by a lack of resources in both funds and people. We could pacify Zabul in probably a year if they pumped money into here like they do Iraq."
As to the number of soldiers, Stofan says: "I see a solution in sight for Afghanistan; its just going to take some more guys." Wei seconds that. "We know how to win here," says Wei. "But were so shorthanded. Every platoon we have is covering what used to be a company-sized sector."
According to the McCaffrey report, while the situation is getting better, "the war in Afghanistan has been shamefully under-resourced by DOD throughout the entire intervention in terms of interagency involvement, U.S. combat forces, political will, and nation-building resources."
Yet together, both wars plus all other defense spending consume about 3.8 percent of gross domestic product, or just over a third of the GDP percentage spent at the height of the Vietnam war. Total U.S. forces currently in both Iraq and Afghanistan amount to just a third of the 540,000 employed for the limited purpose of driving Saddams forces out of Kuwait in 1991. Yet that still might not be a problem in Afghanistan if NATO nations didnt refuse to pull their weight – in total personnel contributed, combat soldiers, or defense expenditures. Only six members spend as much as 2 percent of their GDP on defense. Last year the then-supreme NATO commander said of the alliances efforts in Afghanistan, "We have about 102 national restrictions [the "caveats"], 50 of which I judge to be operationally significant." Even as they refer to America as a bellicose "cowboy" nation, they sit back and let us and a handful of other countries expend the money and blood.
"You can see victory on the horizon," says Wei. "We just dont have the means to get there."
Michael Fumento was embedded in April 2007 with U.S. and Romanian troops in Afghanistans Zabul Province. View his Afghanistan photo set. Read Michael Fumentos additional writing on the military, on Iraq, and on the media, and view his Spring 2006 Iraq photos from both the Fallujah area and Ramadi, his Fall 2006 Ramadi photos. View his 2005 Iraq photos.
Michael Fumento has paid for his military trips entirely out of pocket, including roundtrip airfare to Kuwait, hotels in Kuwait, war insurance, and virtually all his gear. Please support him via PayPal Donate or Amazon Honor System via the logos below.